The New Classics
Kids like doing fun things. Fun may be riding bike, playing Playstation, or chatting on IM (with Congressmen?). Not to be excluded is the child book and now movie series Harry Potter. These fictional tales of a young sorcerer in school teach kids a lot of things about responsibility and cooperation and well as adding creative imagination. Where Harry Potter does not belong, however, is in schools as curriculum.
You wonder why some kids are crazy? Because the parents are crazy! This woman doesn't want to ban HP from school because she wants them to read the classics (which they should be reading). Instead, she thinks its an attempt to indoctrinate wiccans. She's nuts - end of story. But why are we allowing this to be part of their learning? Shouldn't HP be leisure reading? Shouldn't they be perusing Canterbury or Beowulf? And we wonder why our reading and writing scores lack luster.
The one thing, if any, that a student in America should graduate with is an absolute command of the English language in speaking, reading, and writing it. In all honesty, look at yourself and the 10 closest people nearby (they don't have to be family). Now let me ask, do these people have a remarkable capacity to compose their thoughts cogently and scribe them to paper? Can they do it with proper spelling and flawless grammatical semblance? Do they have a presence when they speak and do they enunciate properly? To they understand context and word origin? Is their vocabulary limited or do they impress you with wording out of trite conversation exchange? Are they convincing and do they speak and write with zest and fervor? Do they enjoy it? These are just a few questions to ask yourself and unfortunately the answers to many are probably no. And this is what the standard normal should be!
We may be Americans, and we may speak the language, but that comes up far short to where we should be. Slang, ebonics, etc...a joke. We need to start respecting ourselves, our language, our culture, and our educations a lot more as Americans. We have neglecting this most innate and basic of drives for far to long. Bill Cosby has it right.
Fun is doing what you love and loving doing it. Kids like this Harry Potter so schools think this makes learning more fun. Albeit it may, this is not what they should be doing with their time.
Do it at home. So sure this woman is right in her goal she just has the wrong argument.
So basically, by having HP as a course in school what kind of value on our learning and language does that engender with the student? They say you cant fix stupid - and they're right...even using magic spells.